A separate research project, reported here. Vintage 2026-08-17.
This project set out to test whether tilting new contributions toward markets that are cheap versus their own history beats contributing on a fixed schedule to a fixed allocation. That test cannot be run on this data at any bar worth trusting, and the ruling is binding: see POWER_GATE.md.
The reason is sample size, not sentiment. Markets get cheap together — six separate cheap episodes between 2008 and 2016 are one macroeconomic event seen six times — so three markets pooled hold 3 independent episodes, which is fewer than the charter requires of a single market on its own.
This is the project's headline finding, not a caveat attached to one. “Not answerable on this data” is a complete answer and it was the expected one — written into the charter in advance, before any of it was measured.
NO PHASE-2 QUESTION MAY BE ASKED ON THIS DATA. Not one of the three canonical markets reaches the power the project's own pre-registered arithmetic requires, and neither does the pooled test. The shortfall is not marginal: the best-placed market has 82 of the 155 independent years required, and the worst has 25.
Read the other way round: the edge would have to run at an information ratio of 0.41 to 0.74, depending on the market, before this data could detect it — against the charter's own plausible range of 0.2 to 0.4 for a costed cross-asset value overlay. The problem is not that the answer is uncertain. It is that the edge would have to be larger than such an overlay plausibly is.
These two projects have different denominators and different bars. Valquo's trial register and TIDEMARK's are separate budgets, so a number from one may not be compared with, averaged against, or read as corroborating a number from the other.
There is no combined verdict, and there will not be one. Valquo measures a cross-sectional stock ranking; TIDEMARK measured whether cross-asset rotation is answerable at all. Neither result is evidence about the other.
| Project | Trials (N) | Critical value √(2·ln N) | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| TIDEMARK | 66 | 2.89 | TIDEMARK's own budget, at its own vintage. Vintage 2026-08-17. |
| Valquo — equity | 307 | 3.3843 | Valquo's own budget, derived at render time. |
| Valquo — options | 324 | 3.4002 | Valquo's own budget, derived at render time. |
A market at the 90th percentile with twelve independent episodes gets a band you can act on. One at the 90th percentile with two gets a band so wide that the honest caption is “we cannot tell you what this implies.” Both are legitimate outputs, so the tier is stated before the number, in words, on every card.
Where it sits: the percentile plus or minus 1.96 standard errors, computed at the effective sample size (raw observations divided by the measured design effect), never at raw n — a raw-n interval would be three to ten times too narrow.
What it implies: 1.96 divided by the square root of the episode count — the tightest interval that count could support, in standard deviations. It needs no return data at all. Both are approximations and are labelled as such.
| ACTIONABLE | A band you can act on At least 12 independent episodes AND enough independent history to support a test. The reading means something you could lean on. |
0 markets |
| INDICATIVE | Suggestive, not decisive Clears the charter's 4-episode kill condition and the anchor is admissible, but the record is too short to support a test. Read the direction, not the magnitude. |
0 markets |
| NOT INTERPRETABLE | We cannot tell you what this implies Fewer than 4 independent episodes, or the anchor is inadmissible, or its episode count is not robust to how the count is taken. The percentile is a true statement about the past and supports no inference about the future. |
0 markets |
| REFUSED | No number is shown, deliberately There is not enough of its own history for a percentile to mean anything. The refusal is the output, not a gap waiting to be filled. |
0 markets |
The two tiers at the top are empty, and that is the finding rather than an oversight. They are shown so the scale is visible: this dashboard is capable of saying “you can act on this”, and on this data it never does.
2026-08-17, limit 90 days.
Derived statistics only — percentile, episode count, effective n and band half-width. No
source series is reproduced on this page. Sources behind the figures, in the
TIDEMARK project: POWER_GATE.md,
PREREG_ANCHOR_SELECTION.md,
PREREG_P1_GATE.md,
scripts/p1_8_dashboard.py.